Failure Assessment of an In-Service Pressure Vessel with Crack Flow Using Failure Assessment Diagram (FAD) Method

Wira Herucakra, Christina Dewi R.I. Simanjuntak

Abstract


Failure assessment include fatigue assessment was performed for an in-service pressurize equipment utilized to support hydrocarbon proceesing activity as the response of crack-like flaw finding during phase array scanning inspection. The assessment required to ensure the integrity and the safety in the operation of deteriorated pressure vessel.  The fitness-for-service assessment in this study are consist of  failure assessment using Failure Assessment Diagram (FAD) and the fatigue assessment based on API 579-1/ASME FFS-1. The assessment has demonstrated that the current condition of the equipment was pass the assessment requirement and still has adequate strength and the fatigue damage due to actual operation pressure is an insignificant factor affecting the life of the equipment. This study also investigates the correlation between the geometry of the flaw and the stress increase ratio that is expressed in the exponential function as σC/σR = 4.18e0.82(LD/T^2)


Keywords


API RP 579-1/ASME FFS-1; Crack-like Flaw; Fitness-for-Service Assessment; Failure Assessment Diagram; Pressurise Equipment

Full Text:

PDF

References


Maurice Stewart. “Surface Production Operations: Volume 5: Pressure Vessels, Heat Exchangers, and Aboveground Storage Tanks: Design, Construction, Inspection, and Testing”. Gulf Professional Publishing, 2021.

American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME). “Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section VIII: Rules of Construction of Pressure Vessel”, 2023.

American Petroleum Institute (API). “API 510: Pressure Vessel Inspection Code: In-service Inspection, Rating, Repair and Alteration, 11th Edition”. 2022.

American Petroleum Institute (API). “API Recommended Practice 580: Risk Based Inspection 4th Edition”. 2023.

American Petroleum Institute (API). “API 579-1/ASME FFS-1: Fitness for Service 4th Edition”. 2021.

M. Ghanbari, M.J. Ranjbar Naserabadi and F. Mirzadeh. “Evaluation of a pressure vessel using failure analysis diagram based on phase array ultrasonic testing data”. Journal of Structural Integrity and Maintenance 2022, Vol. 7, No. 3, 198-205.

American Petroleum Institute (API). “API 579: Recommended Practice for Fitness for Service”. Washington DC, 2000

British Energy. “British Energy R-6: Assessment of the integrity of structure containing defect”. 1999

British Standard Institute. “BSI 7910: Guide on method for assessing the acceptability of flaw in structure”. 1999

Ted L. Andreson and David A. Osage. “API 579: A Comprehensive Fitness for Service Guide”. International Journal of Pressure Vessel and Piping, 77 (2000) 953-963.

David A. Osage. “Fatigue Assessment for In-Service Component – A New part for API 579-1/ASME FFS-1 Fitness for Service”. Procedia Engineering 133 (2015) 320-347.

American Petroleum Institute (API). “API 579-1/ASME FFS-1: Fitness for Service 3rd Edition”. 2016

Junk-Suk Lee, Jung-Bog Ju, Jae-il Jang, Woo-Sik Kim, Dongil Kwon. “Weld Crack assessment in API X65 pipeline: failure assessment diagram with variations in representative mechanical properties”. Material Science and Engineering A 373 (2004) 122-130.

Sebastian Cravero, Claudio Ruggieri. “Structural integrity analysis of axially cracked pipeline using conventional and constraint-modified failure assessment diagrams”. International Journal of Pressure Vessel and Piping 83 (2006) 607-617.

S.T. Lie and T. Li. “Failure pressure prediction of a cracked compressed natural gas (CNG) cylinder using failure assessment diagram”. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 18 (2014) 474-483.

Macros A. Bergant, Alejandro A. Ywny, Juan E. Perez Ipina. “Failure Assessment Diagram in Structural Integrity Analysis of Steam Generator Tubes”. Procedia Materials Science 8 (2015) 128-123.

W. Wu, G.X. Cheng, Y. Li, Q. Zhou, H.J. Hu. “Failure Assessment of cracked pipes based on failure assessment diagram considering random and Fuzzy uncertainties”. Procedia Engineering 130 (2015) 1298 – 1310.

R.A. Ainsowrth, M. Gintalas, M.K. Sahu, J. Chattopadhyay, B.K. Dutta. “Application of failure assessment diagram methods to cracked straight pipes and elbows”. International journal of pressure vessels and piping 148 (2016) 26 – 35.

G, Pluviange, O. Bouledroua, M. Hadj Meliani, Rami Suleiman. “Corrosion defect analysis using domain failure assessment diagram”. International journal of pressure vessel and piping 165 (2018) 126 – 134.

Bassam Gamal Nasser Muthanna, Omar Bouledroua, Madjid Meriem-Benziane, Mahdi Razavi Setvati, Milos B. Djukic. “Assessment of corroded API 5L X52 pipe elbow using modified failure assessment diagram”. International journal of pressure vessels and piping 190 (2021) 104291.

Tsutomu Iwashita, Yoshiaki Kurobane, Koji Azuma, Yuji Makino. “Prediction of brittle fracture initiating at ends of CJP groove welded joint with defect: study into applicability of failure assessment diagram approach”. Engineering Structure 25 (2003) 1815-1826.

Z.M. Yang, S.T. Lie, W.M. Gho. “Failure assessment of cracked square hollow section T-Joints”. International Journal of pressure vessel and piping 84 (2007) 244-255.

S.T. Lie, Z.M. Yang, W.M. Gho. “Validation of BS7910:2005 failure assessment diagram for cracked square hollow section T-, Y- and K-joints”. International Journal of Pressure Vessel and Piping 86 (2009) 335-344.

Xudong Qian. “Failure Assessment diagram for circular hollow section X- and K-joints”. International journal of pressure vessels and piping 104 (2013) 43 – 56.

Aziz Ahmed and Qudong Qian. “A deformation limit based on failure assessment diagram for fatigue-cracked X-joint under in-plane bending”. Ships and offshore structure, 2016, Vol. 11, No. 2, 182 – 197.

V. Madrazo, S. Cicero, T. Gracia. “Assessment of notched structural steel components using failure assessment diagram and the theory of critical distances”. Engineering failure analysis 36 (2014) 104 – 120.

S. Cicero, V. Madrazo, T. Gracia. “On the assessment of U-shaped notched using failure assessment diagram and the line method: experimental overview validation”. Theoretical and applied fracture mechanic 80 (2015) 235 – 241.

S. Cicero, T. Gracia, V. Madrazo. “Structural integrity analysis of notched ferritic steel operating within their ductile to brittle transition zone: an approach from failure assessment diagram and the notch master curve”. Engineering failure analysis 58 (2015) 134 – 148.

Jiangchao Zhu, Mauro Madia, Michael Schurig, Bernard Fedelich, Harmut Schlums, Uwe Zerbst. “Brust speed assessment of aero-engine turbine disk based on failure assessment diagram and global stability criterion”. Engineering fracture mechanic 277 (2023) 109005.

Giorgio Donzella, Candida Petrogalli. “A failure assessment diagram for component subjected to rolling contact loading”. International journal of fatigue 32 (2010) 256 – 268.

G. Donzella, C. Petrogalli and A. Mazzu. “Application of failure assessment diagram under rolling contact with hardness variable along the depth”. Procedia engineering 10 (2011) 746 – 751.

Giorgio Donzella, Angelo Mazzu. “Extension to finite life of failure assessment diagram for contact fatigue loading”. International journal of fatigue 44 (2012) 217 – 224.

Douglas A. Scarth, Ted Smith. “The use of failure assessment diagram to describe delayed hydride cracking initiation at a blunt flaw”. International Journal of pressure vessel and piping 79 (2002) 233-243.

C.M. Davies, N.P. O’Dowd, D.W. Dean, K.M. Nikbin, R.A. Anisworth. “Failure assessment diagram analysis of creep crack initiation in 316H stainless steel”. International journal of pressure vessel and piping 80 (2003) 541 – 551.

S. Jallouf, K. Casavola, C. Pappalettere, G. Pluvinage. “Assessment of undercut defect in a laser welded plate made of Ti-6Al-4V titanium alloy with probabilistic domain failure”. Engineering failure analysis 59 (2016) 17 – 27.

F.T. Ibanez-Guiterrez, S. Cicero. “Fracture assessment of notched short glass fibre reinforce polyamide 6: an approach from failure assessment diagram and the theory of critical distance”. Composite part B 111 (2017) 124 – 133.

Macros A. bergant, Alejandro A. Ywny, Juan E. Perez Ipina. “A comparison of failure assessment diagram option for Inconel 690 and incoloy 800 nuclear steam generator tubes”. Annals of nuclear energy 140 (2020) 107310.

Sergio Cicero, Victor Martinez-Mata, Marcos Sanchez, Sergio Arrieta. “Analysis of additively manufactured PLA containing notched using failure assessment diagrams”. Procedia Structural integrity 42 (2002) 18 – 26.

S. Cicero, M. Sanchez, V. Martinez-Mata, S. Arrieta, B. Arroyo. “Structural integrity assessment of manufactured ABS, PLA and graphene reinforced PLA notched specimen combing failure assessment diagram and the theory of critical distance”. Theoretical and applied fracture mechanic 121 (2022) 103535.

Sergio Cicero, Sergio Arrieta, Marcos Sanchez, Laura Castanon-Jano. “Analysis of additively manufacture notched PLA plates using failure assessment diagrams”. Theoretical and applied fracture mechanic 125 (2023) 103926.

Hongzhou Yan, Huayan Chen, Maobing Shuao, Xiangguo Zeng, Bin Huang. “Thermal stresses of large-dimension of lithium hydride ceramic during the sintering process and strength analysis based on process-based failure assessment diagram”. Ceramics international 50 (2024) 3930 – 3939.

T.L. Andrson. “Fracture Mechanic: Fundamental and Application – Third Edition”. CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group. 2005

Vishal Metha. “Evaluation of the Fracture Parameter for SA 516 Grade 70 Material”. IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering (ISOR-JMCE) Volume 13, Issue 3 Ver. III (May-June. 2016), PP 38-45.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12962/j25481479.v9i2.20414

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Abstracted / Indexed by:
      
  

 

 

 

 

 

P-ISSN: 2541-5972   

E-ISSN: 2548-1479

 

Lisensi Creative Commons

IJMEIR journal published by  Department of Marine Engineering, Faculty of Marine Technology, Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Surabaya Indonesia under licenced Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International Licence. Based on https://iptek.its.ac.id/index.php/ijmeir/