Selecting The Best Route for Aerial Ladder Truck to Speed Up Response Time in High-Rise Buildings Located in Unprotected and High Fire Risk Areas

I Dewa Made Frendika Septanaya, Putu Gde Ariastita, Fendy Firmansyah, Faradhyba Rizky Ramadhana

Abstract


Fire outbreaks on high-rise buildings require specific techniques and equipment; one of such equipment is aerial ladder trucks. Firefighters in aerial ladder trucks must ideally arrive at the location of the fire within the ideal response time constraint in the context of fire emergency management to minimize collateral damage, be it of human lives or properties. This study aims to discover the best route traversable by aerial ladder trucks to achieve the ideal response time should a fire occur in high-rise buildings, particularly stated buildings located within unprotected and high fire risk areas in Sidoarjo Regency. The best routes were selected through a simulation using the closest facility in GIS Network Analyst based on proximal distance and travel time. The study results show that the aerial ladder trucks can traverse the recommended routes to the high-rise buildings within the ideal response time. However, the majority of these results only occur during off-peak hours. Hence, the addition of new fire stations, whose locations are within 5 km of the high-rise buildings, and the improvement or addition of street networks as an alternative to increase the fulfillment of the ideal response time of aerial ladder trucks, especially during peak hours, are recommended.

Keywords


Closest Facility, Fire, GIS Network Analyst, High-Rise Building, Response Time

Full Text:

PDF

References


N. Maryantika. and C. Lin. “Exploring changes of land use and mangrove distribution in the economic area of Sidoarjo District, East Java using multi-temporal Landsat images.” Information Processing in Agriculture., Vol.4, No.4 (2017, Dec.) 321-332.

BPS Kabupaten Sidoarjo, PDRB Kabupaten Sidoarjo Atas Dasar Harga Berlaku Menurut Lapangan Usaha (2010-2020). Available from: https://sidoarjokab.bps.go.id/statictable/2019/07/31/60/pdrb-kabupaten-sidoarjo-atas-dasar-harga-berlaku-menurut-lapangan-usaha-2010-2020-.html (2021).

BPS Kabupaten Sidoarjo, Kabupaten Sidoarjo dalam Angka 2020. Available from: https://sidoarjokab.bps.go.id/publication/2020/04/27/ae347c4e214566fac7797915/kabupaten-sidoarjo-dalam-angka-2020.html (2020).

N. Challands, “The relationships between fire service response time and fire outcomes.” Fire Technology., Vol.46, No.3 (2010, Oct.) 665-676.

Z. Drezner, and H.W. Hamacher, Facility Location: Applications and Theory. Berlin: Springer (2004).

K. KC, J. Corcoran, and P. Chhetri, “Measuring the spatial accessibility to fire stations using enhanced floating catchment method.” Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, Vol.69 (2020, Mar.).

A.T. Murray, “Optimising the spatial location of urban fire stations.” Fire Safety Journal, Vol.62 (2013, Nov.) 64-71.

S. Shahparvari,S, M. Fadaki, and P. Chhetri, “Spatial accessibility of fire stations for enhancing operational response in Melbourne.” Fire Safety Journal, Vol.117 (2020, Nov.).

G. Craighead, High-Rise Security and Fire Life Safety 3rd Edition. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann (2009).

D. Liu, Z. Xu, L. Yan, and F. Wang, “Applying real-time travel times to estimate fire service coverage rate for high-rise buildings. Applied Sciences, Vol.10, No. 19 (2020, Sep.).

G. A. Harrison, and E. Budnick, “The high-rise fire problem.” CRC Critical Reviews in Environmental Control, Vol.4, No.1-4 (1974) 483-505.

X. Liu, H. Zhang, and Q. Zhu, “Factor analysis of high-rise building fire reasons and fire protection measures.” Procedia Engineering, Vol. 45, (2012) 643-648.

K. T. Q. P. Nguyen, P. Mendis, P, and S. Fernando, “Novel modelling approach for evacuation strategies of tall towers - A case study of Lotus Tower.” Journal of Building Engineering, Vol. 25 (2019, Sep.).

S. M. Algharib, “Distance and Coverage: An Assessment of Location-Allocation Models for Fire Stations in Kuwait City, Kuwait.” Thesis, Postgraduate Program of Geography. Kent State University (2011).

S. Boluri, A. Vafaeinejad, A. A. Alesheikh, and H. Aghamohammadi, “The ordered capacitated multi-objective location-allocation problem for fire stations using spatial optimization.” International Journal of Geo-Information, Vol.7, No. 2 (2018, Jan.).

S. Kanellakos, S. Fire station location study – phase 1. Available from: https://app06.ottawa.ca/calendar/ottawa/citycouncil/cpsc/2008/10-02/04-ACS2008-CPS-OFS-0001.htm (2008).

I. Macit, “Solving fire department station location problem using modified binary genetic algorithm: a case Study of Samsun in Turkey.” European Scientific Journal, Vol.11, No.30 (2015).

National Fire Protection Association, Standard for the organization and deployment of fire suppression operations, emergency medical operations, and special operations to the public by career fire departments. Available from: https://www.nfpa.org/codes-and-standards/all-codes-and-standards/list-of-codes-and-standards/detail?code=1710 (2010).

J.R. Oppong, K. Boakye, R. Edziyie, A.Y. Owusu, and C. Tiwari, “Emergency fire response in Ghana: The case of fire stations in Kumasi. African Geographical Review, Vol.36, No.3 (2016, Aug.) 253-261.

L. Yang, B. F. Jones, and S.-H. Yang, “A fuzzy multi-objective programming for optimization of fire station locations through genetic algorithms.” European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.181, No. 2 (2007) 903-915.

J. R. Hall, High-Rise Building Fires. Available from: https://technokontrol.com/pdf/elpes/oshighrise.pdf (2013).

ESRI. (2018) ESRI Training. Available from: https://www.esri.com/training/.

A. Kamilaris, and F. O. Ostermann, “Geospatial analysis and the internet of things.” International Journal of Geo-Information, Vol.7, No. 7 (2018).

W. E. Marshall, D. P. Piatkowski, and N. W. Garrick, “Community design, street networks, and public health.” Journal of Transport & Health, Vol.1, No.4 (2014, Des.) 326-240.

P. Y. Park, W. R. Jung, G. Yeboah, G. Rempel, D. Paulsen, and D. Rumpel, “First responders’ response area and response time analysis with/without grade crossing monitoring system.” Fire Safety Journal, Vol.79, (2016) 100-110.

D. Schrank, and T. Lomax, The 2007 urban mobility report. Available from: https://static.tti.tamu.edu/tti.tamu.edu/documents/umr/archive/mobility-report-2007-wappx.pdf (2007).

L. P. Beland, and D. A. Brent, Traffic and the Provision of Public Goods [Working Paper]. Department of Economics, Louisiana State University (2018).

D. Brent, and L.-P. Beland, “Traffic congestion, transportation policies, and the performance of first responders.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, Vol.103 (2020).

Properti Indonesia, Adu Strategi BUMN Properti. Jakarta: Total Megah Media Nusa (2017).




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12962%2Fj2716179X.v16i2.9916

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Jumlah Pengunjung

 

Creative Commons License

Jurnal Penataan Ruang by LPPM ITS is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Based on a work at https://iptek.its.ac.id/index.php/jpr/index.

https://venator.edu.pl/

http://ametconstruct.pl/

toto macau

https://dobraprzestrzen.edu.pl/

https://chars.edu.vn/

slot gacor

situs toto

slot gacor

slot777

slot gacor

slot gacor

nana4d

rokokbet

Owner: BABON

slot88

https://cl.submission.scielo.org/

https://acadscij.uodiyala.edu.iq/

<a >Owner: J4M4L

SLOT777

SLOT88

SLOT88

SLOT777

SLOT777

https://portal.stikespmc.ac.id/

https://smujo.id/biodiv/

https://jurnal.umbarru.ac.id/

https://semarangloker.id/

https://jurnal.kpk.go.id/

slot777

slot88

slot777

slot777

slot88

slot777

https://ceeratjsd.com/

<a >Owner: BANG TABOLABALE

slot777

Slot88

slot88

Slot88

Situs gacor

Situs toto

<a >Owner: SKYLIGHT

Slot Gacor

Rtp Slot

slot777

Situs gacor

Slot88

slot88

Situs Toto

FOR4D

TOTO 4D

https://revistascientificas.us.es/

https://godisnjak.pf.unibl.org/

https://eprosiding.upsi.edu.my/

https://shiowlabersinar.com/

https://shiowlaterbit.com/

https://isrcpk.com/contact/

https://freshlyinformed.com/

https://rumahjurnal.net/sagacious

<a >FR13NDS

slot777

https://khabarshi-kkb.uz/

https://books.unipamplona.edu.co/

https://www.cjolis.org/

https://ijssn.com/

https://data-science.semuniver.kz/

https://legalitas.semuniver.kz/

https://oyshyl.semuniver.kz/

https://spil.journals.ac.za/

slot777

slot777

slot777

slot777

<a >KEEPLAYHANDPHONE-2

slot88

Slot777

Slot777

Slot777

slot777

BESTAM

matauangslot

https://rasapedia.id/

for4d

slot88

rtp slot

shiowla

for4d

toto 4d

shiowla

https://nana4djuara.com/nana4d-penyedia-bocoran-angka-prediksi-sydney-hari-ini-bocoran-togel-sdy-2d-3d-4d-jitu-akurat/

satgas damai cartenz bongkar scatter hitam dari modal ratusan ribu jadi puluhan juta dior ss26 dan fenomena slot cuan dari modal puluhan ribu ke koleksi mewah scatter hitam di mbg jadi sorotan masbro nd ingatkan negara jangan kalah main Strategi Anak Kos Surabaya Uang Jajan 50 Ribu Berbuah Rp.247.600.000 Juta di Mahjong Ways 2 Main Mahjong Ways 2 Saat Gabut Mahasiswa Ini Panen Uang Rp240.600.000 Dengan Modal 60 Ribu 40 Ribu Berubah Jadi Rp 150 Juta Mahasiswa Ini Bikin Kaget ! Cuma Main Mahjong Langsung Dapat Rp 5 Juta ! Gimana Caranya Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Mahjong Wins Guliran 19! Montir Rian Bandung Lunasi Sewa Bengkel Mahjong Wins RTP 94,3 di NEGO77 Montir Dinamo Starter Raka di Bandung yang Awalnya Bertahan dengan Hutang Warung, Kini Bisa Bangkit Berkat Mahjong Wins di NEGO77 dengan RTP LIVE 94,2% Guliran 22! Montir Wahyu Solo Sukses Mahjong Wins RTP 94,4 di NEGO77 Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Ways 3 Kasih Rp32Jt! Montir Bayu Palembang Bangkit RTP 93,8 di NEGO77 Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Modal 60Rb! Montir Bima Cilegon Cuan Mahjong Wins 3 RTP 95,2 di NEGO77 Modal 70Rb! Montir Tono Yogya Menang Mahjong Wins 3 RTP 95,5 di NEGO77 Modal Tipis! Montir Hendra Semarang Senyum Usai Menang Mahjong Wins 2 RTP 95,0 Scatter Hitam NEGO77 Montir Body Repair Rizky di Pekanbaru Justru Kantongi Rp27.800.000 dari Servis Nissan March Lalu Menang di Mahjong Wins di NEGO77, Berkat Scatter Hitam dengan RTP LIVE 93,7% Montir Yoga Tangerang Raih Rp32,4Jt L300, Menang Mahjong Wins RTP 94,0 di NEGO77 Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Penjahit Sepatu Cikarang Aktifkan Double Chance Mahjong Wins di UJI77 Modal Rp45.000 Tembus Rp32.400.000 Beli Mesin Jahit Industri Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Putaran 11! Montir Adi Semarang Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Fortuner RTP 93,9 di NEGO77 Putaran 15! Montir Aldi Tangerang Menang Mahjong Wins 3 City RTP 94,3 di NEGO77 Putaran 15! Montir Gilang Pekalongan Menang Mahjong Ways 2 RTP 94,5 di NEGO77 Rp31,9 Juta! Montir Arman Palembang Menang Mahjong Ways 2 RTP 93,7 Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Spin 13! Montir Fajar Surabaya Menang Mahjong Ways 3 RTP 94,5 di NEGO77 Spin 16! Montir Jaka Palembang Pecahkan Mahjong Wins 2 XL7 RTP 96,2 di NEGO77 Spin 18! Montir Fahri Bogor Menang Mahjong Ways 1 RTP 94,3 di NEGO77 Spin 19! Montir Dani Medan Jackpot Mahjong Wins 2 Xpander RTP 96,2 di NEGO77 Spin 21! Montir Fery Bekasi Cuan Mahjong Ways 2 City RTP 95,4 di NEGO77 Spin 26! Montir Andri Semarang Tenang Usai Menang Mahjong Ways 3 RTP 95,8 Spin 27! Montir Andri Tangerang Tenang Lagi Mahjong Ways 3 RTP 95,9 Spin 28! Montir Joko Bandung Pecahkan Mahjong Ways 2 Calya RTP 95,8 di NEGO77 Mahjong Wins Mahjong Wins Trik 8 Detik! Montir Bima Cilegon Tambah Cuan Mahjong Ways 1 Luxio RTP 92,6 di NEGO77 Trik 9 Detik! Montir Rio Yogya Tambah Cuan Mahjong Ways 1 Sirion RTP 92,8 Harga Emas Melojak Tajam Live RTP Menjadi Acuan di Mahjong Ways 3 Seorang Kakek di Jawa Tengah Terkejut Menemukan Scatter Hitam di Mahjong Ways Resep Masak Scatter Hitam Ala Ala Masakan Server Jepang Jefcol Pemuda Asal Malang Menang Besar di Mahjong Ways 3 Berkat Bantuan Scatter Hitam Riski Pecahkan Rekor Kemenangan di Mahjong Ways 3 For4D Bermodal Live RTP dan Pola Mesin777 Scatter Hitam Meledakkan Dimas Si Supir Metromini Yang Mendapatkan Banjirnya Scatter Hitam Begini Caranya Unutuk Mendapatkan Scatter Hitam Mahjong Ways 2 DI FOR4D dapatkan cuanmu sekarang bermain mahjong ways SCATTER HITAM Nongol Terus di Mahjong Ways 2 For4D Arif Punya Cara Mudah Menang Cuan Gak Ada Henti Saldo Meledak Tips dan Trik Menaklukkan Scatter Hitam di Permainan Mahjong Ways 2 Rahasia buk Santi Sang Penakluk Naga Hitam Ganas Terungkapnya Rahasia Bermain di Mahjong Ways 3 Lengkap dengan Tutorial Fenomena Scatter Hitam Resep Masakan Bu Siti yang Mendadak Viral dan Jadi Perbincangan Warganet Bu Guru Salsa Viral Usai Bermain Scatter Hitam di Mahjong Ways 3 Boy Mahasiswa Asal Jakarta Bagi Bagi Saldo Dana Gratis Usai Menang 88 Juta di Mahjong Ways Rahasia Terbaik Lele dengan Bibit Asli Scatter Hitam Auto Cuan Tiap Hari Strategi Anak Kos Surabaya Uang Jajan 50 Ribu Berbuah Rp.247.600.000 Juta di Mahjong Ways 2 RTP presisi Mahjong Wins 3 kombinasikan Tak Disangka Pekerja Angkat Sawit dengan Gaji Kecil Berubah Jadi Bos Sawit Setelah Menang Mahjong Ways 2 Teknik Scatter Hitam Bocor Dari Joni Operator Bengkel Surabaya Modal 35K Tembus Jackpot 198 Juta Berkat Pola Panda Habanero RTP Tinggi Heboh Modal Receh Seratus Ribu di Mahjong Ways 2 Mengubah Pemain Jadi Trader Crypto Sukses dengan Cuan Fantastis Viral Modal Kecil Bermain Mahjong Ways 2 Bisa Mengantarkan Pemain Jadi Bos Tambang Emas Mendadak Dari Hidup Pas Pasan Pemain Mahjong Ways 2 Mendadak Jadi Juragan Perkebunan Setelah Raup Kemenangan Fantastis Berawal dari Modal Receh di Mahjong Ways 2 Pria Desa Kini Jadi Pengusaha Properti Muda yang Sukses Rahasia Scatter Hitam Mahjong Ways 2 yang Jarang Terungkap Pemain Desa Jadi Kaya Mahjong Wins

Dari Sawah ke Sydney-Hongkong: Perjalanan Tak Biasa Seorang Petani

Viral Seorang Warga Kabanjahe Jadi Miliarder Usai Coba Bermain di Aplikasi Togel 4D

https://aeriumanalytics.com/news/kisah-ismawati-petani-jawa-barat-yang-terbang-ke-sydney-hongkong-bermain-togel-4d-dan-menang-rp-10-juta.html

https://aeriumanalytics.com/news/viral-seorang-warga-kabanjahe-jadi-miliarder-usai-coba-bermain-di-aplikasi-togel-4d.html

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-chatuchak-terbaru-hari-ini-01-oktober-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-pattani-terbaru-hari-ini-01-september-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-hongkong-terbaru-hari-ini-rabu-01-oktober-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-pcso-terbaru-hari-ini-rabu-01-oktober-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/nusantaraprediksi-prediksi-togel-singapore-hari-ini-rabu-01-oktober-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-praha-terbaru-hari-ini-rabu-01-oktober-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-sydney-terbaru-hari-ini-rabu-01-oktober-2025/

https://nusantaraprediksi.com/prediksi-nusantara-hadir-dengan-prediksi-togel-cambodia-terbaru-hari-ini-rabu-01-oktober-2025/

RTP LIVE

RTP LIVE

RTP LIVE

RTP LIVE

RTP LIVE

RTP LIVE

Owner: syndicateseo

mega4d

bandar togel

situs toto

mega4d

https://www.ecobasalto.pt/

mega4d

https://bsorj.uomustansiriyah.edu.iq/

mega4d

https://mega4dboy.com/

mega4d

mega4d

https://mega4dkami.xyz/

https://linkr.bio/mega4d-toto

https://mega4dsukses.xyz/

https://mega4dtop.xyz/

https://mega4dsalju.xyz/

https://mega4dsama.xyz/

https://mega4dofficial.id/

mega4d

slot777

https://sarynjournal.kz/