Comparison of Embankment Reinforcement Requirements with Geotextile on Soft Soil with 2D and 3D Slope Stability Analysis Methods

Nur ‘ Arfiati Shoffiana, Yudhi Lastiasih, Trihanyndio Rendy Satrya

Abstract


Slope stability analysis is very important in slope design so it can manage and maintain the infrastructure assets. If the slope is unstable, it can damage the infrastructure around the slope. The method commonly used in slope stability analysis is 2D modeling which assumes the length of the landslide area is not limited or continuous. In fact, landslides that occur in the field are limited and not continuous, so 3D modeling is more suitable than 2D modeling. 3D slope stability analysis has been developed by various researchers. Most of the results of previous studies stated that the 3D and 2D factor of safety ratio was more than one for cohesive soils and less than one for non-cohesive soils. This safety factor affects the amount of reinforcement needed. Differences in 2D and 3D safety factors will cause differences in the amount of reinforcement needed. Therefore, this study was conducted to determine the differences in the 2D and 3D slope stability analysis result. Slope stability analysis was carried out using LEM, where the 2D slope stability used the Fellenius method while the 3D slope stability used the Hovland method. Calculate the required reinforcement amount using geotextiles with Tult = 250 kN/m. The results obtained from this study are the 2D safety factor is smaller than the 3D safety factor. The 3D and 2D safety factor ratios range from 1.09 – 1.397. While the amount of reinforcement required in the 3D analysis is less than in the 2D analysis with the ratio of 3D and 2D reinforcement requirements ranging from 0.5 to 0.955 depending on the width and height of the embankment.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Bahsan, E. & Fakhriyyanti, R. (2018). “Comparison of 2D and 3D Stability Analyses for Natural Slope”. International Journal of Engineering & Technology 7 : 662-667

Chen, R.H. (1981). Three-Dimensional Slope Stability Analysis. IN: Purdue University. West Lafayette. Indiana.

Chen, R.H. & Chameau, J.L. (1982). “Three-dimensional Limit Equilibrium Analysis of Slopes”. Geotechnique 32(1): 31-40.

Dana, H.Z, Kakaie, K.R., Rafiee, R., & Bafghi, A.R.Y. 2018. ”Effects of Geometrical and Geomechanical Properties on Slope Stability of Open-Pit Mines Using 2D and 3D Finite difference methods”. Journal of Mining & Environment 9 (4) : 941-957.

Das, B.M. (1985). Mekanika Tanah (Prinsip-prinsip Rekayasa Geoteknik) Jilid II. Diterjemahkan oleh Mochtar N.E., dan Mochtar I.B. Erlangga. Jakarta

Gens, A., Hutchinson, J.N., Cavounidis, S. 1988. “Three-dimensional analysis of slides in cohesive soils”. Geotechnique 38(1) : 1-23.

Sari, P.T.K, et al. (2020). “The Comparison Between 2-D and 3-D Slope Stability Analysis Based on Reinforcement Requirements”. Advanced Science Engineering Information Technology 10(5) : 2082-2088.

Septiandri, R.A, et al. (2021). Metode Cepat Untuk Menentukan Besar Pemampatan Konsolidasi (Sc) Pada Timbunan Di Atas Tanah Lunak dan Perencanaan Perkuatannya Untuk Kondisi Dengan dan Tanpa Pemasangan Prefabricated Vertical Drain (PVD). Tesis Pasca Sarjana. Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember (ITS) Surabaya

Septiandri, R.A., et al. (2021). “Analisis Kebutuhan Perkuatan Geotextile untuk Tinggi Timbunan Badan Jalan yang Bervariasi di atas Tanah Lunak pada Kondisi dengan dan tanpa Pemasangan PVD (Prefabricated Vertical Drain)”. Jurnal Aplikasi Teknik Sipil 19 (3) : 283-294.

Shoffiana, N.A., et al. (2021). Perbandingan Hasil Analisa Stabilitas Lereng 2-D dan 3-D terhadap Jumlah Kebutuhan Perkuatannya. Tugas Akhir. Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember (ITS) Surabaya.

SNI 8460:2017. Persyaratan Perancangan Geoteknik. Badan Standarisasi Nasional. Jakarta.

Sugiarto et al (2022). “Analisis Penyebab dan Mekanisme Keruntuhan Lereng Sungai Konaweha, Studi Kasus Ruas Bts. Kab. Konawe Utara/Kab. Konawe – Pohara Km 29+750”. Jurnal Manajemen Aset Infrastruktur & Fasilitas - JMAIF 6(Khusus1) Januari 2022.

Suprayitno, H. & Soemitro, R.A.A. (2018). “Preliminary Reflexion on Basic Principle of Infrastructure Asset Management”. Jurnal Manajemen Aset Infrastruktur & Fasilitas – JMAIF 2(1) Maret 2018.

Suprayitno, H. et al (2020). “Preliminary Reflection on Performance Indicator and Performance Factor for Infrastructure Asset Management”. Journal of Infrastructure & Facility Asset Management - JIFAM 2(1), March 2020.

Wardani, M.K. et al (2019). “Evaluasi Potensi Kelongsoran Pada Lereng Alam Akibat Perubahan Sudut Kemiringan Menggunakan Metode Fellenius”. Jurnal Manajemen Aset Infrastruktur & Fasilitas. Vol. 3, Edisi Khusus 2, Juni 2019.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12962%2Fjifam.v4i2.14369

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


 

Visitor :

Author Affiliate Statistics

View My Stats

 

 Flag Counter

Flag Counter


  

 

Creative Commons License
Journal Of Infrastructure & Facility Asset Management by Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Cendanatoto

Situs Toto

http://earthlearning.unimol.it/

https://flz.sabu.edu.ly/

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Slot Thailand

Cendanatoto

Slot Gacor

Slot Gacor

Toto Slot

Toto Slot

Cendanatoto

Slot Gacor

Slot Dana

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Kementerian Pemberdayaan Perempuan dan Perlindungan Anak Indonesia

BRIN - Badan Riset dan Inovasi Nasional

Cendanatoto

Toto Togel

https://wapresi.id

https://liputannewstoday.id/

pedia288

pedia288

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

https://kemkessumut.id/

https://maritimeacademy.id/

https://kadinlanggur.id/

Okejitu

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Kapital4D

KapitalSlot

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Cendanatoto

Situs Slot Gacor Maxwin

Pedia288

CendanaToto

Pedia288

CendanaToto

Pedia288

CendanaToto

Pedia288

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Pedia288

Kapital4D

Pedia288

KapitalSlot

Pedia288

Kapital4D

KapitalSlot

KapitalSlot

KapitalSlot

KapitalSlot

KapitalSlot

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

Rejekibet

KapitalSlot

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

KapitalSlot

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

Okejitu

CendanaToto

CendanaToto

Slot777

Slot Gacor

Kapital4D

KapitalSlot

CendanaToto

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

Slot Gacor 4D

Kapital4D

Pedia288

Slot 4D

CendanaToto

Pedia288

KapitalSlot

Kapital4D

Slot Online

Slot Gacor 4D

CendanaToto

Toto Slot

CendanaToto

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Kapital4D

Slot Gacor 777

Kapitalslot

Slot Gacor 4D

Toto Togel

Slot Gacor

Situs Toto

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

Pedia288

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Pedia288

Okejitu

Kapital4D

KapitalSlot

Pedia288

Kapital4D

Okejitu

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Okejitu

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Pedia288

Okejitu

Kapital4D

PEDIA288

TOTO SLOT

TOTO TOGEL

CENDANATOTO

Scatter Hitam

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

https://www.cityofnorthfield.org/

Kapital4D

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

cendanatoto

cendanatoto

cendanatoto

cendanatoto

cendanatoto

cendanatoto

cendanatoto

Slot Thailand

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Slot777

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Slot777

toto slot

Okejitu

CendanaToto

Pedia288

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Cendanatoto

Okejitu

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Pedia288

KapitalSlot

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

rumahpusbin.org

jurnal-desa.id

RSUD Madiun

simakuniga-desa.id

RSUDBM

RSUD Ulin Banjarmasin

Tabalongkub

Website Resmi Bogor TimurIndonesia

Madiun

TabolakkabResmi Kabupaten Konawe Selatan

Rumah Pangan KitaDistribusi Pangan Resmi Peluang Usaha Modal Terjangkau

Direktorat Jenderal PajakTerkini Dan Terpercaya

Rita Hazan

Potretterkini

Kabupaten MadiunIndonesia

al-ainrestaurants.com

Rumah Sakit Umum Kabupaten KendalMasyarakat Selalu Hidup Sehat Dan Bahagia

Toko-Pedia

Kadin SumateraSistem Informasi Kamar Dagang Industri Indonesia

Caplang

Buka Lapak

Toko Sepatuh

Kadin Sumatera SelatanSistem Informasi Kamar Dagang Industri Indonesia

Kadin Sumatra Utara

k

Kota DemakTerkini Dan Terbaru Hari Ini

Berita Kota MadiunTerkini dan Terbaru Hari ini

RS UIUniversitas Indonesia

BUDHI DARMA INDRAPURA

Rumah Sakit Umum RSUD CicalengkaProvinsi Jawa Barat

Kabupaten Tasikmalaya

Badan Amil Zakat Nasional

KABUPATEN KAPUAS

Sidbankumda

DisnakerTrans

Berita Madiun

KatinganKab

Children's NationalHospital - Ranked Top 10 in the Nation

Murni Teguh Memorial HospitalKota Jakarta

Mayo ClinicRochester,Minnesota

RS PersahabatanKota Jakarta Timur

RS Adam Malik MedanTerjangkau, Efisien, Nyaman

(RSUD) Dr. Dradjat PrawiranegaraKabupaten Serang

pafiipalembang.org

hipmijatengprov.org

hipmidemakk.org

pafiibandung.org

pafitebingtinggii.org

parikotajakarta.org

parikotalubuklinggau.org

hipmikotamedan.org

parikotalhokseumawe.org

hipmisiantar.org

hipmikisarankota.org

parikotalangsa.org

hipmikalimantan.org

parikotamakassar.org

pafiipalembang.org

hipmikotakediri.org

Okejitu

parikotabatam.org

Pedia288

hipmisubangkota.org

hipmisumatra.org

hipmisumatra.org

parikabpapuabarat.org

Pedia288

hipmisulawesi.org

hipmitenggara.org

hipmisumatraselatan.org

hipmisumatrabarat.org

paficabangmedankota.org

pafisiabu.org

pafisingkuang.org

pafiparit.org

paritegall.org

parijawa.org

paribandahaceh.org

parikabpapuabarat.org

parikotamedan.org

pariprovmedan.org

parikotajogja.org

parikotasiantar.org

parikotapapua.org

paripapuautara.org

Toto Slot

Cendanatoto

Slot Thailand

Pedia288

https://kemkespapuaselatan.id/

https://kemkespapuapegunungan.id/

https://kemkespapuatengah.id/

https://kemkespabarprov.id//

https://kemkesmalukuprov.id/

https://kemkessultengprov.id/

https://kemkeskalselprov.id/

https://kemkeskaltengprov.id/

https://kemkesbengkuluprov.id/

https://kemkesjambiprov.id/

https://kemkeskepriprov.id/

https://kemkesriau.id/

https://kemkesumbarprov.id/

https://kemkesacehprov.id/

https://simonakemkes.id/

https://jatengprov.org/

https://kotajatengprov.org/

https://jdih-kemkes.id/

BMKG - Badan Meteorologi, Klimatologi, dan Geofisika Indonesia

pedia288

pedia288

Cendanatoto

Toto Slot

Slot Gacor

Toto Slot Gacor

Slot Gacor 777

Slot Gacor Resmi

Situs Slot88 Gacor

Slot Bet 200 Perak

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Online Gacor

Slot Bet 200 Resmi

Slot Gacor 777

Slot Thailand Resmi

Slot Gacor 4D

Slot Online Gacor

Slot Online Terbaru

Slot Modal Receh

Slot Banjir Maxwin

Slot Online

Slot Online Gacor

Slot Gacor 777

Slot Thailand

Slot Pulsa

Slot Scatter Hitam

Slot Gacor 4D

Slot Super Gacor

Slot Thailand

Slot Online

Cendanatoto

batiktoto

Kapitalslot

Cendanatoto

Okejitu

Slot Gacor 2025

Bandar Toto Resmi

Slot Gacor

Slot Online

Slot88

Situs Slot Gacor

Slot88

Slot Bet 200

Slot Bet Kecil

Slot Gacor 2025

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Online

Slot Scatter Hitam

Slot777

Slot Gacor 2025

Slot Gacor

Slot Dana

Okejitu

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

Kapital4D

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Bandar Togel Terpercaya

Slot Gacor

CENDANATOTO

SLOT777

SLOT MAXWIN

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Slot Gacor

CENDANATOTO

CENDANATOTO

CENDANATOTO

CENDANATOTO

fixtoto

Cendanatoto

Prediksi Hk

RUPIAHSLOT

CENDANATOTO

CENDANATOTO

TOTO SLOT

Lohanslot

Lohanslot

Cendanatoto

Kapital4D

Kapital4D

CendanaToto

CendanaToto

KapitalSlot

Kapital4d

Slot Gacor

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

CENDANATOTO

Cendanatoto

Kapital4d

https://quotespics.com/category/humor/

Kapital4d

Bolahoki

BolaHoki

Cendanatoto

Toto Slot

Bandar Togel

CENDANATOTO

CENDANATOTO

CENDANATOTO

Cendanatoto

Slot777

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Toto Slot

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

Cendanatoto

slot toto

situs toto

cendanatoto